Nobel Prize Winning Scientist supports Homeopathy

The French virologist, Luc Montagnier, was awarded the Nobel Prize for Medicine in 2008 after his 1980’s research confirmed the link between HIV and AIDS. 


In September 2010’s issue of 'Homeopathy Healthy Medicine', we wrote how he had presented a speech in which he claimed that water had the ability to retain the memory of a genetic material which was in the same solution, even after it had highly diluted and therefore virtually removed. The disclosure of this information was, naturally, seen as highly controversial by conventional medical professionals since it validated one of the main principles of homeopathy – a substance taken in small, diluted amounts can cure the same symptoms which it would cause if taken in large quantities.

Since the presentation Luc Montagnier has come under fierce criticism by the medical industry for this research but this has not deterred him from his studies. In an interview published in Science magazine in December 2010, his views expressed support for homeopathic medicine. He said, “I can’t say that homeopathy is right in everything. What I can say now is that high dilutions (used in homeopathy) are right. High dilutions of something are not nothing. They are water structures which mimic the original molecules." 

There is support for Luc Montagnier by another Nobel Prize winner, Brian Josephson, who described, in New Scientist magazine, how scientists today suffer from “pathological disbelief”, whereby they maintain an unscientific attitude, concluding that “even if it were true I wouldn’t believe it”. 


The result, cited by both men as real phenomena, deserve further study, in the hope that future investigations may help to increase our understanding of the working mechanism of homeopathy.

This article was first published in issue 16 of 'Homeopathy Healthy Medicine'. 

These newsletters are published by the ARH each month, and provide information about homeopathy that is usually not available to the public in our mainstream media. ARH makes them available to everyone as free downloads, and they can be used for information, marketing and publicity purposes.

Eating Disorders and Homeopathy

Our food isn't what is was. Our eating habits are not what they were. And there is little doubt that the problem of 'eating disorder' is very much on the increase. It has been estimated that there are at least 1.1 million people in the UK affected by eating disorders, with young people aged 14-25 most at risk of developing this illness, and with 10 times more women than men suffering from either anorexia or bulimia. More statistics can be found here.

Recovering from an eating disorder can take a long time, and there are many treatments, including cognitive behavioural therapy, inter-personal psychotherapy, dietary psychodynamic counselling. There is also conventional medication. The NHS Choices website mentions SSRI drug treatment. SSRI's are antidepressants, known to have some very serious adverse reactions, especially if taken over a long period. And in long-term use there is the danger of serious withdrawal problems. Moreover, whilst SSRI drugs might deal with the depression that can often be a background factor, I know of no evidence that these drugs can, or do treat eating disorder directly.

Homeopathy is an alternative medical treatment for those suffering from an eating disorder. As an holistic therapy it has the advantage of treating the individual as an individual, recognising that he/she has his/her own reasons for developing the disorder. So, as suggested in this article, the homeopath may want to go back to the earliest years of life, to childhood eating patterns, and wider familial and social issues that might have led to the eating disorder.

In going into this background, the homeopath is looking for a remedy that is known to have 'similar' characteristics to the individual's personal experience of the disorder. The basis of homeopaths is 'treating like for like', and remedy selection is crucial. This article, by a leading homeopath, Robin Murphy, gives some examples of the remedies that have been found to be useful in the treatment of eating disorder. Take a look, and see how each remedy has a different 'symptom picture'. Here are just three examples, taken from the article.


Arsenicum album - Extreme fastidiousness especially about germs and dirt. Anorexia coupled with fear of being poisoned. Fear of getting certain diseases so they starve.



Phosphoric acid - Etiology: grief with loss of appetite with emaciation, pining away from loss of love, second stage they get indifferent to all emotions and food. Deadness inside. Grief - anorexia than some chronic disease.



Pulsatilla - Feeling of worthlessness, unloved, loneliness, fixed ideas about. Food especially certain foods are bad, than amount of foods that are bad grows, fear of gaining weight, pulsatilla's gain weight easily, they can eat a pastry and swear they gained weight. .... Pulsatilla (patients) ... are constantly weighing themselves. Scanty menses.

Just these simple descriptions demonstrate that the homeopath is not primarily interested in the condition, anorexia or bulimia; but more in the person who is suffering from the condition.

So does homeopathy work? For those who wish to know more, this 'qualitative enquiry into the use of homeopathy for eating disorders' discusses the approach of the homeopath in more detail. The primary objective of the enquiry was to determine whether homeopaths found homeopathy effective in treating the whole person; mentally, emotionally as well as physically. This is the conclusion.

".... the findings show that homeopathy has an effect on all levels; mentally, emotionally as well as physically, which means that homeopathy has no difficulty in combining the physical side of the disorder with the mental aspect of it, and therefore offers a more complete form of therapy than any other type of treatment. The findings indicate, that by concentrating on the underlying reasons the eating disorder appeared in the first place, addressing the central disturbance and aetiology, homeopaths in actual fact connect with the patients, building an honest mutual therapeutic relationship so that the patients stick with the treatment".

We are currently in 'Eating Disorders Awareness Week. So, if you would like to discuss the homeopathic treatment of eating disorders with a local homeopath go to this website.